
In the anti-aging care aisles, it’s hard to miss them. Retinol, retinal and bakuchiol are now competing for a place of choice in serums and creams intended to fight the first signs of aging. All three promise smoother skin, a more even complexion and less visible wrinkles. However, behind these marketing promises hide very different molecules, which do not have the same scientific perspective.
Because although retinol has been studied for many years, retinal is attractive due to its proximity to the active form of vitamin A, while bakuchiol stands out as an alternative of plant origin, often presented as gentler. But which one to choose when you want to prevent skin aging or reduce already established wrinkles? And above all, is it necessary to favor the most powerful active ingredient to obtain good results? Here’s what you need to know before making your choice.
1. Retinol: the safe bet to act on the signs of aging
Derived from vitamin A, retinol belongs to the retinoid family. Its interest in cosmetics is based in particular on its ability to stimulate cell renewal and act on several mechanisms involved in skin aging. It thus helps to improve the texture of the skin, reduce fine lines, even out the complexion and reduce the appearance of certain pigment spots. It is also associated with stimulating the production of collagen, a protein essential for maintaining skin firmness.
Its main advantage? It benefits from a relatively significant scientific perspective compared to the other active ingredients in this comparison. A systematic review published in 2024 in the journal , which analyzed 32 clinical studies on different anti-aging cosmetic ingredients, gives it a high level of recommendation, grade A. It is therefore a particularly interesting active ingredient for people who wish to integrate real anti-aging care into their routine.
Its main disadvantage, however, remains its tolerance. When introduced too quickly or used in too high a concentration, retinol can cause redness, tightness, stinging sensations, and peeling. This adaptation period is sometimes called “retinization.” To limit these inconveniences, it is better to start with a low concentration, apply the product two evenings a week, then gradually increase the frequency depending on the reaction of your skin. The use of a complementary moisturizer is also recommended.
Editor’s choice:
2. Retinal: a more powerful alternative to retinol?
Also called retinaldehyde, retinal also belongs to the retinoid family. It is a derivative of vitamin A, but its particularity lies in its proximity to retinoic acid, the biologically active form which acts directly on skin cell receptors. To understand the difference with retinol, we must look at their transformation in the skin: retinol must undergo two conversion steps to become retinoic acid, while retinal only requires one.
This proximity explains why retinal is often presented as a more powerful and potentially faster active ingredient than retinol. It is particularly studied for its benefit on wrinkles, texture irregularities and signs of photoaging. A randomized clinical study published in 2018 in the evaluated two concentrations of retinaldehyde, 0.05% and 0.1%, in 40 women showing signs of photoaging. After three months of use, researchers observed an improvement in skin texture in both groups, as well as better skin hydration.
However, should it be considered systematically superior to retinol? Not so fast. Although its conversion mechanism makes it particularly interesting, comparative clinical studies remain fewer than for retinol. Its tolerance also depends on the concentration, formulation and individual sensitivity. It can also cause irritation, especially at the start of its use. It therefore constitutes an interesting option for people who already know retinoids and wish to move on to a more advanced active ingredient, provided they respect a gradual introduction.
Editor’s choice:
3. Bakuchiol: the plant-based alternative for sensitive skin?
Bakuchiol is often presented as “plant retinol”. Extracted mainly from the seeds of the plant, also called babchi, this ingredient has antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. Unlike retinol and retinal, it is not a derivative of vitamin A. It nevertheless acts on certain biological pathways involved in skin aging, which explains why it is being studied as an alternative to retinoids.
Its main argument is its tolerance. In a study published in 2019 in the , researchers compared the effects of bakuchiol and retinol on the signs of photoaging. For 12 weeks, 44 participants applied either a cream containing 0.5% bakuchiol twice daily or a cream containing 0.5% retinol once daily. Both groups showed a significant reduction in wrinkle area and hyperpigmentation, with no statistically significant difference between the two treatments. In contrast, people using retinol reported more tingling and flaking sensations.
These results are encouraging, but they must be interpreted with caution. The study involved a small number of participants and over a relatively short period of time. A systematic review published in 2024 on anti-aging cosmetics also gives bakuchiol a recommendation level of grade C, compared to A for retinol. In other words, there is interesting clinical data, but it is still insufficient to confirm that bakuchiol is as effective as retinoids in the long term. It nevertheless represents an interesting avenue for people who cannot tolerate retinol, who are looking for a gentler routine or who wish to avoid retinoids.
Editor’s choice:
Retinol, retinal or bakuchiol: which one to choose depending on your skin type?
| Criteria | Retinol | Retinal | Bakuchiol |
|---|---|---|---|
| Family | Vitamin A | Vitamin A | Plant active |
| Anti-aging action | Very documented | Promising | Encouraging |
| Conversion in skin | 2 steps | 1 step | No conversion to retinoic acid |
| Tolerance | Possible irritations | Possible irritations | Generally well tolerated, but possible reactions |
| Level of evidence | Important | More limited | Still limited |
| Interesting profile | First signs of aging | Users already accustomed to retinoids | People looking for an alternative to retinoids |
There is no universal anti-aging active ingredient that would suit all skin types. The choice depends above all on your goals, your skin sensitivity and your experience with the active ingredients. For a first anti-aging routine, retinol remains a safe bet thanks to its scientific history and its documented benefits on the signs of photoaging. It is particularly interesting for gradually improving skin texture, fine lines and pigmentary irregularities.
Retinal may be considered if you have used retinoids before and your skin tolerates them well. Its more direct conversion into retinoic acid makes it a particularly interesting active ingredient, even if the available data does not allow it to be declared systematically superior to retinol. Finally, bakuchiol constitutes an alternative to consider when the priority is tolerance. It may be suitable for people whose skin responds easily to retinoids, although its anti-aging benefits are even less well documented.
In all cases, it is better to favor regularity rather than multiplying powerful assets. Introducing several retinoids simultaneously does not necessarily provide better results and increases the risk of irritation. It is also essential to use daily sun protection: UV rays remain one of the main factors in skin aging. Finally, topical retinoids should be avoided during pregnancy as a precaution. If in doubt, particularly during breastfeeding or if your skin has a dermatological pathology, seek advice from a healthcare professional.
FAQ: questions we ask about anti-aging active ingredients
1. What is the difference between retinol and retinal?
Both are derivatives of vitamin A. Retinol requires two conversion steps in the skin to become retinoic acid, while retinal requires only one. It is therefore considered closer to the active form of vitamin A, but its clinical superiority over retinol is not systematically demonstrated.
2. Is bakuchiol as effective as retinol?
A clinical study published in 2019 observed comparable improvements in certain signs of photoaging after 12 weeks of use. However, scientific data on bakuchiol remains less numerous. It is therefore too early to say that it has equivalent effectiveness to retinol in the long term.
3. Which anti-aging active ingredient should you choose when you have sensitive skin?
Bakuchiol can be an interesting option for skin that has difficulty tolerating retinoids. Retinol and retinal can also be used by certain sensitive skin, provided you choose a low concentration and introduce them very gradually. In case of persistent redness or irritation, it is better to discontinue use and seek advice from a dermatologist.
4. Can you use retinol and bakuchiol at the same time?
Some cosmetic formulations already combine the two ingredients. However, there is no need to overlap them to obtain better results. If your skin tolerates this combination well, it can be considered, but it is better to avoid multiplying active ingredients when starting an anti-aging routine.
5. Can you use retinol or retinal during pregnancy?
As a precaution, topical retinoids, including retinol and retinal, are not recommended during pregnancy. It is preferable to replace them with assets not part of this family, after consulting a health professional. Bakuchiol is not a retinoid, but safety data during pregnancy remain insufficient to recommend it without reservation.