They accumulate on supermarket shelves and in our bathrooms. Practical, fragrant, accessible, shower gels are part of the daily routine of millions of consumers. But behind their innocuous appearance, certain products present risks for the skin.
Why this shower gel is pinned by 60 million consumers
Among the 81 references analyzed by 60 Million consumers, one particularly caught the attention of investigators because of its wording. This is the Labell Pomegranate and Melon shower gel, marketed by Intermarché. This product obtained an E rating in the Cosmeto’Score, the lowest in the ranking established by the magazine. This negative evaluation is based on the presence of an ingredient considered problematic for the skin, particularly in people who are sensitive or prone to skin reactions.
Presented as a fruity shower gel at an affordable price, the product is singled out for including a preservative classified among the most allergenic substances identified in dermatology. Daily use of this formula is considered worrying in the context of repeated contact with the skin.
A controversial conservative at the heart of criticism
The main complaint made by 60 Million consumers concerns the presence of methylchloroisothiazolinone in the formula of Labell shower gel. This preservative, used to limit the development of bacteria and extend shelf life, is identified as a frequent contact allergen.
This substance is among the most problematic compounds in dermatology. Its repeated use can lead to skin sensitization, with skin reactions ranging from redness to itching, or even contact eczema in the most severe cases.
If its antimicrobial effectiveness is not called into question, it is its irritant potential which gives rise to concern. Simple contact with a product containing it may be enough to trigger a reaction in a sensitized person. It is on this basis that the Cosmeto’Score gives an unfavorable rating to the product.
Should you continue to use this shower gel every day?
Daily use of a shower gel containing methylchloroisothiazolinone may represent a risk for people with sensitive skin, prone to irritation or skin allergies. Repeated contact with this type of formula is likely to weaken the skin barrier, particularly in children or users with a dermatological predisposition.
The classification in grade E in the Cosmeto’Score is based in particular on the presence of this ingredient, associated with a recognized allergenic potential. This assessment does not mean a ban, but it draws attention to a necessary level of vigilance, particularly in the context of frequent use.
60 Millions of Consumers recommends carefully examining the composition of hygiene products, in particular to avoid certain preservatives or irritating agents. Reading the list of ingredients and referring to the labels or comparisons available allows you to guide your choices according to your skin profile and sensitivity.
FAQ – What you need to know before choosing a shower gel
1. How to spot a potentially irritating shower gel in store?
Check the ingredients list on the back of the bottle. Certain preservatives, such as those ending in “-isothiazolinone”, or sulfates (SLS, SLES), should be avoided if you have sensitive skin.
2. What does an “E” grade mean in the Cosmeto’Score?
This is the lowest mark on the scale. It indicates a composition considered unfavorable, due to substances controversial for health or the environment.
3. Is methylchloroisothiazolinone still authorized in cosmetics?
Yes, but its use is regulated. Certain categories of products have seen its concentration limited, or even prohibited, depending on the type of application.
4. Is there a risk-free alternative to traditional shower gels?
Cold saponified soaps, syndets (soap-free dermatological bars) or certified organic gels are often better tolerated, especially for reactive skin.
5. Is a poorly rated shower gel necessarily dangerous?
Not necessarily. A bad rating indicates points for vigilance regarding the composition, but the real risk depends on your frequency of use, your skin type and your personal sensitivity.
